Rubi Stephani Hellwege: Why Two Patients With the Same Cardiac Output Can Be Completely Different
Rubi Stephani Hellwege, Intensive Care Medicine Physician in Specialty Cardiology Training at University Hospital Zurich, shared a post on LinkedIn about a recent article by Maurizio Cecconi et al., published in Intensive Care Medicine, adding:
“Venous Return vs Cardiac Function: Who drives the circulation?
A fascinating new review by Cecconi, Ostermann and Pinsky revisits one of the oldest questions in cardiovascular physiology:
Does cardiac output depend primarily on the heart or on venous return?
The answer is: both.
The heart can only pump the blood that returns to it, but adequate organ perfusion also depends on the heart’s ability to generate pressure and sustain flow.
For me, the most important clinical message is that shock cannot be understood by looking at a single variable.
In daily practice we often focus on:
- Cardiac output
- Blood pressure
- LVEF
- CVP
But the circulation is an integrated system involving:
- Venous return
- Cardiac function
- Arterial tone
- Tissue perfusion
- Venous congestion
This is why two patients with the same cardiac output may have completely different physiology and outcomes.
The figure in the paper beautifully illustrates something we see every day in the ICU:
A fluid challenge may increase cardiac output in a preload-responsive patient with preserved cardiac function.
The same fluid challenge in a patient with impaired cardiac function may mainly increase filling pressures, venous congestion, and organ dysfunction.
This is why I believe haemodynamic assessment should move beyond the question:
‘Will this patient increase stroke volume?’
and include:
‘Can this patient tolerate more volume?’
Perhaps this is also why one-size-fits-all haemodynamic protocols continue to struggle in critical care.
At the bedside we are not treating diagnoses.
We are treating physiology.”
Title: Venous return versus cardiac function: who drives the circulation?
Authors: Maurizio Cecconi, Marlies Ostermann, Michael R Pinsky
Stay updated with Hemostasis Today.
-
Nov 8, 2026, 19:31Anna Kajaste-Rudnitski: Presenting AAV-Induced p53 Signalling in Human CNS Cells at ESGCT 26
-
Nov 8, 2026, 19:29David McIntosh: Cybersecurity Matters, but Blood Availability Remains the Bigger Challenge
-
Nov 8, 2026, 19:26Wenxue Ma: An Integrative Framework for Macrophage-Mediated Therapeutic Resistance in Cancer
-
Nov 8, 2026, 19:25Yildiz Yigit: Presenting a Polycythemia Vera Case at the MPN Subcommittee Session
-
Nov 8, 2026, 18:56Denis Oduor: Strengthening the Regulation and Delivery of Blood Transfusion and Transplantation Services
-
Nov 8, 2026, 18:28Raghavendra Rao: A Narrative Review on Chronic Venous Disease during Pregnancy
-
Nov 8, 2026, 17:57Dhiren Patel: PLD1-Derived Phospholipids Regulate NAD Kinase and ROS Production in Neutrophils
-
Nov 8, 2026, 17:48Andra T.: What Causes Antiphospholipid Syndrome? – Four Steps, not One Cause
-
Nov 8, 2026, 17:38Nasrin Samadi: Can a Normal Clotting Test Be Misleading?